5 Common Stick Welding Mistakes That Ruin Weld Quality

Many poor stick welds can be blamed on one of five things, not the gods or faulty hardware. If your beads are full of pinholes, bubbling, or slag entrapment, the solution is often less expensive than a new welding machine. It may just be one of the following problems.

You’re Using The Wrong Rod for The Job

Picking up the nearest electrode on the shelf is a fast road to welding disaster. Every rod in the AWS classification system is designed with a job in mind. E6010 and E6011 are designed to dig deep and punch through rust, mill scale, and dirty pipe joints. That makes them perfect for field repairs, and total overkill for any clean-burning sheet metal work. E6013 is designed for an easy, smooth arc on thin material. That’s why it’s often the first rod a lot of beginners ever pick up. It’s also totally unsuited for anything structural, or even any job where you need low-hydrogen rod protection.

E7018 is the rod most guys default to when they are welding structural steel. It uses a low-hydrogen flux that helps the bead take in all welding positions. However, if you’re welding clean material flat in the shop you are just flat-out wasting the rod’s potential. The numbers in the classification aren’t meaningless. They tell you tensile strength, welding position, and flux type before you even strike an arc. If you aren’t even certain what rod category your base metal and joint design falls into, you can review standard rod categories here to see which one matches the job in front of you. That isn’t just some minor detail either. It’s the decision that really determines if everything downstream will work.

Damp Electrodes are Quietly Wrecking Your Bead

Low hydrogen rods such as E7018 tend to absorb moisture from the atmosphere the moment you open the box. This moisture converts to hydrogen during the welding process. High hydrogen content results in porosity and cold cracking, which often can develop several hours after welding when the weld appeared to be perfect and cooled. If you know your base metal is clean and you are still getting random pinholes, the moisture in your flux coating is your number one suspect.

AWS D1.1 code requires any open low hydrogen electrode to be stored in a rod oven set between 250-300°F (121-149°C). Rods left on the table in a damp shop, in the truck bed for a week, or even over the weekend can easily exceed the AWS allowed limits on moisture content and require rebaking before you can use them. If you are going to use low hydrogen rods, a rod oven is not an optional piece of equipment in the shop – it could mean the difference between a job that cracks up after the customer leaves and one that doesn’t.

Amperage That’s too High or Too low

Amperage is the variable most beginners fight with, and it’s usually set by guesswork instead of the manufacturer’s chart. Too much current on thin material burns through and leaves undercut along the toes of the weld. Too little current makes the rod stick to the plate, sputters instead of arcing cleanly, and leaves slag clinging stubbornly to the bead instead of lifting off on its own.

Start with the rod diameter and the manufacturer’s recommended range, then adjust on a scrap piece of the same thickness before touching the actual joint. A weld that looks flat and lifeless with heavy slag sticking is almost always running cold. One that’s spattering everywhere with a deep, aggressive crater is running hot.

Arc length and Travel Speed are Drifting

A long arc will oxidize the molten metal, throwing spatter all over the workpiece and weakening the deposit since the shielding gas released from the flux coating is insufficient to cover the puddle. Short arc discipline matters more than most welders admit – you want the rod close enough that the arc sounds tight and controlled, not a loose crackle.

Travel speed is also a problem all its own. Move too quickly and the bead comes out narrow, humped, and likely to trap slag. Move too slowly or jerkily and you wind up with a wide, flat bead that lacks fusion at the toes. Most important of all, however, is for the welder to maintain a steady, comfortable speed. A steady, even pace with a short arc gives you a bead that looks the same from start to finish, which is exactly what you want.

Dirty Base Metal and Sloppy Stops

Rust, oil, and scale as well as old paint do not only stay on the surfaces while welding – they also boil into the molten metal and cause holes or contamination, which often leads to pores in the welded joint. The grinding or the wire-brushing of the base metal takes only a few minutes and does not require a lot of work, but it easily prevents costly errors that you otherwise would have to grind out and re-weld.

A second common cause for a lousy joint is the careless stop-and-restart. If a weld end is not rounded off by filling up the remaining little hole, there will be a depression, a starting point for many cracks. With the restart, do not start directly at the depression but overlap the end of the adjacent bead about half an inch. This way, the fresh weld metal makes a connection to good metal.

None of these five mistakes require new equipment to fix. They require paying attention to the variables you already control – rod selection, moisture, amperage, arc length, and how you handle the base metal and your stops. Fix those one at a time and the ugly welds mostly disappear on their own.

For more information please visit our blog.